Andriano Cattaneo on Starting Solids for Babies

Babies don't like processed baby foodsAs part of the online Gold Conference on breastfeeding, I attended a webinar with Italian physician Adriano Cattaneo entitled “Principles for the Introduction of Starting Solids.”

Dr. Cattaneo’s comments on prepared baby foods reminded me of my post about what makes processed foods bad. His reasons for avoiding jarred food for babies include:

  • Contaminants like heavy metals, additives and colorings.
  • False nutritional claims. This is especially true regarding fats and vitamins. And because of their long shelf life, the quality of the food deteriorates.
  • The quality of these components is poor. To increase profits, manufacturers prefer cheap starches and oils.
  • The foods have no taste or fragrance, with an unpleasant look and texture. Babies don’t like them.
  • They are expensive and harm the environment (think of all of that glass!).

Most of these concerns apply to the processed foods that adults eat as well. However, because babies are still growing, the quality of their food has a greater long-term effect. Babies and toddlers have small stomachs, so it’s important to make every bite count.

Cattaneo also recommends against spoon-feeding of pureed soups or mixed vegetables even when homemade.  Babies need control over their food, including how much they take in each bite, how much of each particular food they want (as opposed to mixtures), and when to stop.

In fact, Cattaneo advises that babies are ready for solids as soon as they grab them and eat them. Babies who get everything they need from breastmilk, or who are not physically ready, won’t bother. Most babies show interest during the range of 4 to 9 months, with most babies nearer to the 6-month mark a few outliers, especially at the later end. Despite the recent, poorly evidenced recommendations adopted by most European countries and Israel, there is no reason to be worried if  your baby doesn’t want solids despite being older than 26 weeks.

Babies enjoy learning to manipulate solid foods and experimenting with flavors and textures. Parents can encourage this by inviting baby to eat along with them at meals. Breastfeeding babies are already used to the flavors of the mother’s diet. Feeding babies is about much more than getting the correct amount of protein, calcium and fat into their stomachs. It’s about trusting babies’ instincts to get what they need, and encouraging their inborn desire and ability to imitate their parents and learn adult skills.

Related posts:

9 Great Reasons to Cook with Your Kids

Cooking for a Family with a New Baby

Starting Solids the Easy Way

Make Your Own “Convenience” Foods for Your Baby

Should Toddlers Eat Dessert?

image: Fimb via Flickr 


  1. I don’t agree at all with her recommendations against spoonfeeding altogether. At 11 months, my baby is very capable at feeding herself. At 6 months, she wasn’t at all, and even when she started to finger feed herself, she often got tired or bored before she was really full and then was hungry for a meal about a half hour later as opposed to when I fed her pureed food and she was full for about 2 hours. I fed her until she turned her face and refused more food, let her suck the food off of the spoon and certainly never forced her to eat what she didn’t want. How is that not controlling her food intake?

  2. Abbi, thanks for sharing your real-life experience. At 6 months most babies are generally not ready for a whole meal of solids or a jar of baby food–their ability to get more finger foods into their stomachs generally increases with their appetite and their need for less breastmilk.
    You stopped the meal when baby was clearly done, but not all do. And with finger foods, the baby has a choice about how much of each type of food he or she wants.

  3. There are so many differences among children — all eight of my kids sat on my lap at meals and started grabbing food off my plate between 5.5 and 6.5 months.

    But my grandson wouldn’t do that, even when he clearly needed more than breast milk (a full nursing satisfied him for a short time only), when he was much older than 6 months, even at well over a year. She fed him by hand, letting him turn his head to reject food. Even at 18 months, he rarely puts food in his mouth, he prefers pulling his mother’s hand — with food in it — so it goes into his mouth.

    So, I agree with everybody. Let little ones feed themselves — unless they don’t. 🙂


  1. […] periodo comienza aproximadamente a los seis meses de edad (algunos un poco antes, algunos bastante después), que es cuando empiezan a mostrar interés por la comida, a tener habilidad para llevársela a la […]